Napa Insider
Do One Thing Well / by Christina Julian / April, 2016

What is an upscale sports bar? Im certain theres an oxymoron in there somewhere.

Last month I commented on the large number of retailers and restaurants leaving established space in St. Helena in favor of a new home in Calistoga. No sooner did that column go to print than I learned of another up-valley blow. Calistogas JoLe, home to a coconut cream pie I dubbed the best dessert in the valley, closed in January despite packed houses and critical raves. The sign tacked up at the restaurant wielded the knife deeper, as it revealed what would become of that space and its neighbor, Barolo.

New owners Michael Dunsford (Calistoga Inn) and his chef, Nicolas Montanez, plan to convert the spaces into an American food, family-style restaurant/raw bar/sashimi/upscale sports bar/whatever else can be smashed into a collective space. Its hard to imagine the food will be as notable as JoLe, given the new proprietors cant seem to make up their mind as to what type of restaurant theme to go for.

And what is an upscale sports bar? Im certain theres an oxymoron in there somewhere. The sports bar side will sit where Barolo once did and offer breakfast, lunch and dinner, along with booze and brews; the bistro side will reside in JoLes former space and feature American classics that Napa Valley is apparently lacking. Sports bar patrons will be able to order from the bistro side menu. Call me snooty, but if I want a sports bar, I go to oneI dont expect to find a sashimi or raw bar at the same time.

Im reminded of one of my fathers more useful tough talks: Decide what you want to do with your life and do it. Doing one thing really well is a lot better than trying to be the be-all/do-all and failing. Spoken like the true IBM man he was. I realize the notion of picking and sticking with one restaurant theme might be antiquated thinking in a time where we text, tweet and post our lives away, but seriously? For the sake of what had started to look like the rise of Calistogas culinary scene, heres hoping Im wrong.

Bring on the barrels

Thankfully there are certain trades, like barrel coopering, that hold tight to that tradition of doing one thing, very well, which I observed when I dropped into Barrel Builders Calistoga warehouse. The company has been in the barrel trade since the early 1970s when it was one of few in Napa Valley. Decades later, while the company cops to using some machinery, it still prefers to do most of the work by hand. We dont have the assembly line scale of doing things here, says owner Phil Burton.

One would think, with exploding markets like China, the demand for French Oak barrels would threaten to dwarf supply, but not so, according to Julien Hittos of Tonnellerie Marchive, Burtons European supplier for French Oak barrels. For every forest that is cut, we automatically replant, so theres no concern of depleted sources. The increase in the barrel market is approximately 1 percent per year, so thats sustainable. For the moment, were not too scared about the future of oak.

Burton entertains me with anecdotes and barrel humor that gets animated when he speaks about the introduction of barrel alternatives (also known as adjuncts or agents): A couple of decades ago, the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau [TTB] was pushed into a ruling. It came out with a line that said, As long as adjuncts arent gunmetal grey or darker than the color of American cigarette tobacco, they could be used in wine. It got to refer to alcohol, tobacco and firearms in one sentence. Of course now [adjuncts are] a huge fixture in winemaking.

So will oak alternatives overtake the use of traditional barrels? If you talk to someone who only sells adjuncts, theyll swear up and down that they can mimic what a barrel does, he continues. But if that was true, why do high-end wineries spend millions of dollars on barrels annually? Of course, I grew up with barrels and think theyre a wonderful, romantic, beautiful container.

Says Hittos, Lately we hear winemakers say they dont want to feel the barrel.

Burton explains: Its this idea that the barrel makes a contribution to the wineits better because of itbut they dont want to know its there. Its the idea that we could design cooperage for specific wines.

Changing with the times is one thing. Trying to be the do-all/end-all is another. But thats just me, a traditionalist at heart.